I like Rozen Maiden, but the best anime I've seen is Princess Tutu. I called myself crazy at first for watching an anime with that name, but now I consider it as a masterpiece. Don't get fooled by the title.
You should have had a "none of the above" and "other" option on that poll, cause I would have clicked on both.
So... which (not witch) anime would I like to fall in love in? Easy enough. Two come to mind... Saiyuki and Witch Hunter Robin. I think Sanzo from Saiyuki and Amon from Witch Hunter Robin are hot... and I do love the anime's setting.
I totally fall in love anyways with all the animes i see/read. oh my heart goes out to so many.